Tags
Controlling river water, Destruction of Mangroves, Mangroves, Nature Strikes Back, Preventing erosion on rivers
Ecuador
Once upon a time in 2008, magnificent mangroves cocooned the Casa Blanca (aka ‘Riverhouse’ and sometimes ‘Casa Loca”) on the last bend of Rio Jama… The few old photos of that house are not very good, but they show the essence of the area in 2008. Note the trees on the both sides of the house.
Some of you are aware of last year’s loss of those mangroves that stood proud and tall downriver from the house. An excavator arrived and began shoving the mangroves into the river. Dump trucks stockpiled huge boulders to replace the trees and strong arm the river into submission, which distressed one artist, and to her dismay, no one else!
How delighted I was when nature bit back and said, ‘That’s enough!”
Another year passed, and the muni erected a grand sign that presided over the final bend in the river. The sign boasted, “Look what we did!” At night the sign’s sea-monster reflection mingled with the ghosts of those lost mangroves.
Two years after the work began, the area remains sterile. At times the strong current undercuts the rocks, which shift and settle at low tide. The barren area provides a great view of the river, but at a loss of the mangroves that once hosted rookeries of egrets, ibis, frigates, herons and cormorants. I’ve adapted, adjusted and still treasure my life on this last bend of the river. The fishermen and the birdlife provide endless photo opportunities!
Last night I bolted to the deck and squinted through the overcast moonlight when I heard, “Plop! Plop!— Ker-plunk! — Ker-Splassssh!” which sounded like elephants jumping into the river! The sound of rushing current, boulders crashing, and waves racing across the river continued for at least five minutes, though other stragglers joined the swimming party for another half hour. The sound of rushing water replaced the usual sweet silence of the river at low tide. Waves lapped near the house, and I pondered, “Did we just have an earthquake? Did somewhere else have an earthquake hours ago, and this is the beginning of a tsunami?”
Slow to panic, I reasoned that the subtle forces of low-tide currents had finally gobbled enough mud beneath the rocks to trigger a domino effect on the big boulders. Like a child anticipating Santa’s arrival, I went to sleep with expectations of dawn.
My downstream neighbors, the fishermen, joined my inspection. Here’s what we discovered:
z
frizztext said:
the municipality’s sign – now kind of a Titanic fate…
P.S.: the trees could not escape: but the birds can.
I like your bird photos! Triumph! And they usually
ignore all municipality’s signs:
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
that was a great photo – the gull and the eagle, but the cat and the paper was a great photo as well!
Gallivanta said:
Sweet revenge but still so sad.
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
yes, i will always miss /mourn the loss of those trees. z
Gallivanta said:
Could you stealthily replant some mangrove?
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
the fill/back fill is rock and gravel.. no topsoil.. no ‘middle’ soil.. at low tide, i could plant in the mud, but the rocks are unsafe!
z
Gallivanta said:
😦
johnandmarylivingitupinecuador said:
Lisa did you ever discover they did that to begin with? Love the photos of the birds.
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
to ‘protect’ the bend? at one time the excavator driver said that i did not understand.. the route of the spondylus was to cross the river right there/downriver (he pointed and said, ‘no intiendo..etc..’ )
that’s like the year’s worth of work at briceno (btween san vicente and canoa) to cross the estero and shorten the drive by TWO MINUTES. that’s all. two minutes.
Alastair said:
What was the purpose of this work? To change the course of the river? Just for the hell of it? Nature will always win either in the short run or the long 🙂
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
‘Just for the hell of it” seems the obvious answer to me, but they truly thought they were doing a service of ‘saving the outside bend’ of the river. over the years i have pointed out how one lone ‘felled’ mangrove does more for stabilizing the river bank than tens of thousands of dollars spent by man’s folly. now there’s nothing on this side of the river to compensate for the trees that fall naturally on the other side, so there’s an acceleration of damage at low tide where the current cuts under the rocks.
one tree every year would have served a much-better purpose.
thanks so much for your interest in what happens on the river here in ecuador!
Madhu said:
‘Why’ is a question that we can keep asking without any hope of answers. The sad part is that when nature bites back it doesn’t harm the people who took those decisions. It is the poor farmers, fishermen and ordinary folk who pay the price. Still, it felt good to see that sign felled 😀
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
yes, you are right about that sign! surely there was a mystical hand at play there! z
hughcurtler said:
Three cheers for Mother Nature! What you have witnessed is a microcosm of what humans are doing to the planet. What’s not clear is whether or not the planet can “bounce back” the way your river seems to be doing. Great post, Z!
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
this last bend of the river has its own cheerleader! i truly think that the birds know that i’m on their side!
and the frogs.. that’s another story!!!!
z
LuAnn said:
How often Mother Earth must despair at how we treat her precious gifts to us. Thanks for this beautiful post Lisa.
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
thank you for your feedback and support! yes, there is so much that is wrong worldwide, but there are also positive things.. we need to start featuring people who are doing things right.. i happen to know a young woman here in jama who is doing just that!
ahem, silvana… let me know when you’re back from quito!
z
LuAnn said:
I love her blog. Thanks for introducing me to her. 🙂
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
you’re welcome, and thank YOU for supporting her! she has an always present smile, and is a deep thinker with a social conscience. she’ll go far! z
babso2you said:
What was that commercial years ago: It’s not nice to fool Mother Nature! Well, it’s not nice to mess with Mother Nature! Love this post! Hey, and congrats to you for the 1st place beach photo! Did you get your award from Nick?
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
no! i’ve been offline a lot, internet problems.. gracias! z
artscottnet said:
Wow, you weren’t kidding, you had some excitement! These are excellent photos, but I’ve come to expect nothing less from you 🙂 The bird photos, especially were a treat to see. Nature’s sting! Glad no one was hurt.
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
i’ll bet those guys will think twice before the linger on those rocks!
that was only one of several unique moments of my day! i am so blessed! z
Rewired and Retired in Nicaragua said:
Oh, Lisa! This is the Lorax of Ecuador. So, let me get this right…they cut all the mangroves to save 2 minutes of travel time? I’m just shaking my head. I hope you saved some seedlings..start planting now. It won’t take long for mother nature to overcome man’s destruction. This horrifies me. I can’t imagine how you felt upon seeing the lovely mangroves ripped apart. But, it sure was rewarding to see the sign crash into the water. I wondered if you considered chaining yourself to the trees…then I read the other post. lol
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
ha! you know me well, and yes, i was ready to make an international scene if they started on the other side of the house! the night herons nest there year round, and i love watching those birds in that clump of trees.!
the two-minute short cut is about an hour down the coast, but the same principle – all of that work to cut out a great bit ‘U’ which to me is one of the sweetest parts of the drive between those two towns!
the mangroves here at the house were shoved one by one, and wow, the crack/crackle, splash etc was pretty hard to take, but i stayed as close as possible to watch what they did. i loved it when the river bit back and the excavator took a swim. unfortunately, tide was going out, so they got it out w/o any damage.
thanks.. z
firstandfabulous said:
Don’t mess with Mother Nature! Don’t these people have more useful things to do? Blah!
On a brighter note, fabulous photos.
Doris said:
so sad, they really do not understand what they are doing,but well great photos, how nice to have a neighbor with a boat, like that picture
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
there are several fishermen who have those old ‘full of character’ canoes. it’s as if time rolled back hundreds of years!
Richard said:
So sad & so universal is man’s assault on nature! Somehow I thought Ecuador was more pristine and would be spared. Did they have some American engineer “consultants”?
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
ja! i think that they had no consultants, unfortunately.
i would like to think that the country as a whole has respect for nature – they have given nature its rights, but it’s hard to know what different municipalities are doing.. a lot like sjo/CR knowing what’s happening in bejuco! it’s ‘done’ before anyone knows what happened.
thanks, as always, richard! z
BobR said:
Very glad to hear that the sign is gone (for now). You’re still living in bird paradise. Some of those shots are great.
btg5885 said:
Was the sky really that pink? It is beautiful.
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
i don’t think so.. that was an old image, and the color seemed off. there have been some unique days, however, when the sky and reflections were a dusty pink.
pommepal said:
So pleased the birds are still there for you. Mother nature may eventually move the rocks around, as she disrupted the sign, and bring more silt down and your lovely birds (with your help) will drop seeds and in time the mangroves may be back. I hope so any way.
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
yes, the rocks are in a much-better position now to slow the current and allow that silt to settle and stay put!
thanks so much! z
shoreacres said:
Last year (or the year before – time goes so quickly) there was a terrible kerfluffle in Houma, Louisiana over some drainage projects. Same deal – bring in the bulldozers, tear down the trees, all in the name of “flood control”. Pfffft.
You know what, though? Nature may not be done yet. Your comment about the current undercutting the rocks made me think of the way the oxbow lakes along the Mississippi are formed. It’s the same principle – unequal flow which scours on one side and silts on the other. It may take a while, but depending on the characteristics of the river and the changes made to the land formation, it’s not impossible that (over centuries) they could turn that baby into an oxbow.
Wouldn’t that be something?
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
yes, this is the final bend in the river, and i often wonder during the rainy season if the river will find the shorter path to the ocean, straight through the mayor’s land!
i grew up on an oxbow lake, and that grand river, and that’s part of the reason i get so frustrated here.. i’ve seen what happens, what works, what doesn’t.. a felled tree works so much better in building a sandbar…
my friends are understanding, b/c i’ll say, ‘see that tree upriver that fell? watch. in a year, you’re going to have a lot more property below that treee.’ and yes, that’s happened.
all people who live near rivers should have to read john barry’s Rising Tide.
ShimonZ said:
Yes, sometimes it’s very sad to see the results of human desire for conquest. Especially when it’s not thought out, and doesn’t try to work in harmony with nature. I too love trees. But I think that what disturbs us most is the infantile recklessness. And as societies develop, we learn how to work with nature instead of trying to conquer her. Liked your story, and your lovely illustrations, Lisa.
Playamart - Zeebra Designs said:
How nice it is to cross paths, (cyber paths!) with like-minded people! As we grow older, we develop an ability to see, to become more sensitive, and to cherish this beautiful world. Thanks so much for your kind comments!
Amy said:
Sometimes Mother Nature bites back, It has happened more often…
Beautiful fishing and river photos, lovely birds 🙂
Pingback: Beach Loss Reaches Critical Status; Community Unites | Zeebra Designs & Destinations